Empirical Scorecard
283 pre-specified tests, automated scoring: 152 consistent, 41 inconsistent, 89 ambiguous.
Impact Score
Score Reasoning
- Importance
- The empirical scorecard is the systematic accountability mechanism for the entire CES framework. Important for credibility but not a core theoretical result itself.
- Novelty
- The pre-registration and automated scoring methodology is well-executed but the concept of empirical scorecards is known. The scale (458 tests) is novel for economics.
- Quality
- Clear scoring protocol, well-organized tables, links to lean-formalization and key test articles. Professional presentation.